SCAM ALERT: Fraudulent emails are being sent using HFK Lawyers' name. Read Important Notice →

Do I need a Shareholders Agreement?

If you’re starting or already running a company with more than one shareholder, one of the most common questions we hear is:

“Do I actually need a shareholders agreement?”

Short answer: if there is more than one shareholder, yes — almost always.
Longer answer: without one, you’re relying on default laws that were never designed to reflect your commercial intentions or protect relationships when things go wrong.

What Is a Shareholders Agreement?

A shareholders agreement is a private contract between the shareholders of a company that governs how the company is owned, managed, and exited.

It sits alongside (but is very different from) the company’s constitution. While the constitution deals with corporate mechanics, a shareholders agreement deals with real-world scenarios — disputes, deadlocks, exits, funding, and control.

Isn’t the Corporations Act Enough?

No.

The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) provides default rules, but those rules:

  • Are generic and one-size-fits-all
  • Do not address commercial realities
  • Do not prevent disputes – they merely resolve them after damage is done

In practice, relying solely on the Corporations Act is technically workable but commercially very risky.

When You Definitely Need One

You should have a shareholders agreement if any of the following apply:

  • There is more than one shareholder
  • Shareholders have different roles (e.g. one works in the business, one doesn’t)
  • Shareholders have invested different amounts
  • The business plans to raise capital
  • You want to control who can become a shareholder
  • You want clarity on what happens if someone leaves, dies, or stops contributing
  • you’re both equal shareholders.

If you don’t document these things early, they are usually documented later — during a dispute, when leverage is uneven and costs are higher.

What Does a Shareholders Agreement Cover?

A well-drafted agreement typically deals with:

1. Ownership & Control

  • Shareholdings and voting rights
  • Reserved matters requiring unanimous or special approval

2. Management & Decision-Making

  • Who runs the company day-to-day
  • Director appointment and removal
  • Deadlock resolution mechanisms
  • These are very important when you have equal shareholders

3. Funding & Capital

  • When shareholders must contribute funds
  • What happens if someone can’t or won’t

4. Transfers & Exits

  • Restrictions on selling shares
  • Pre-emptive rights
  • Drag-along and tag-along rights

5. Bad Leaver / Good Leaver Provisions

  • What happens if a shareholder leaves the business
  • Valuation discounts where appropriate

6. Dispute Resolution

  • Escalation procedures
  • Mediation and arbitration clauses

7. Protection of the Business

  • Confidentiality
  • Restraints
  • Intellectual property ownership

“We Trust Each Other – Do We Still Need One?”

This is the most common reason people delay.

Ironically, trust is the best time to document expectations.

Shareholders agreements are not about mistrust – they are about:

  • Preventing misunderstandings
  • Protecting friendships and family relationships
  • Ensuring clarity when circumstances change

Most shareholder disputes we see don’t start with bad intentions. They start with different memories of what was “agreed”.

What Happens If You Don’t Have One?

Without a shareholders agreement:

  • Disputes default to the Corporations Act
  • Minority shareholders may have more power than intended
  • Exit options become expensive and slow
  • Court proceedings become more likely
  • Business value is often damaged

In many cases, the cost of fixing the problem later is multiples higher than documenting it properly at the start.

The Bottom Line

If you have (or plan to have) more than one shareholder, a shareholders agreement is not a “nice to have” – it is a foundational document.

It protects:

  • The business
  • The shareholders
  • The relationships between them

At HFK Lawyers, we regularly advise founders, family businesses, and investors on drafting shareholders agreements that are clear, commercial, and tailored to how the business actually operates – not just boilerplate templates.

If you’re setting up a company, restructuring ownership, or simply want certainty around your rights and obligations, getting the agreement right early can save significant time, cost, and stress later. Contact us at info@hfklawyers.com.au or 02 9307 8900 and one of our commercial lawyers will contact you to assist.

This Article is

Written By

Get in Touch

We’re Here to Help You

If you have questions about the information presented in this article or need further assistance, our team at HFK Lawyers is ready to assist you. Whether you require legal advice or want to discuss your specific situation, we are just a click away.