A family provision claim allows an eligible person to make a claim against a deceased person’s estate if they believe they have not received adequate provision for their proper maintenance, education or advancement in life, subject to the relevant statutory timeframes.
If you are unsure whether you may be eligible to bring a family provision claim, you can read more about our family provision claim lawyers.
If you are considering whether to challenge or contest a will, you can also learn more about our contesting a will in NSW services.
Time Limits for Family Provision Claims
In NSW, a family provision claim must generally be commenced within 12 months of the death of the deceased person. It is important for potential applicants to be aware of this timeframe, as failing to file an application within time can result in the claim being dismissed.
Extension of Timeframes
An application may be filed “out of time” by consent where the parties to the proceedings agree to waive the time requirement. The Court may also permit a claim to be filed after the expiration of the 12-month period where the applicant can demonstrate sufficient cause.
The factors that may be considered by the Court include:
1. Reason for Delay: Applicants must provide an adequate explanation for the delay in filing. Valid reasons may include a lack of awareness of the contents of the Will, lack of knowledge of the time limit, or personal circumstances that impeded timely action, such as health issues.
2. Prejudice to Other Parties: The Court will consider whether granting the extension would prejudice or unfairly disadvantage the other beneficiaries entitled under the Will. This may include whether the beneficiaries would have been worse off if the claim had begun on the last day of the 12-month period, and whether there have been significant dealings with the estate in the meantime.
3. Strength of the Family Provision Claim: The Court will consider the strength of the family provision claim and whether the claim has sufficient prospects of success. It may be an injustice to refuse an extension where there is no prejudice and the applicant has a strong claim.
If you are considering whether to make or defend a claim and want to understand the potential legal costs involved, you can also read our article on family provision claim costs in NSW.
Case Example: When Might the Court Allow Out of Time Applications?
In Purnell v Tindale [2020] NSWSC 746, an application for an “out of time” family provision claim was made by the nephew of the deceased. The deceased died on 12 August 2016. The nephew was informed of his inheritance about six months after the death of the deceased.
The nephew suffered mental health problems that resulted in other health issues and hospitalisation, which delayed him seeking legal advice until July 2017. He was unable to pay those legal costs upfront and did not contact another lawyer until early 2018, who advised him that his matter was too complicated. During that delay period, he continued to suffer mental and physical health decline.
On his application to the Court in about June 2018, approximately 22 months after death, the nephew claimed his previous lawyers did not inform him of the 12-month limitation period.
The Court found that the nephew had shown sufficient cause for the delay. Six months of the delay was attributed to the nephew’s ignorance of his entitlement under the Will. The Court held that the nephew’s lack of knowledge of the time limit, his severe health issues during the period of delay and his lack of financial resources affected his ability to make the claim in a timely manner.
It is interesting to note that the nephew ultimately failed in his claim for further provision because he was not an eligible person. You can read more about eligibility in our related article, Who Can Contest a Will in NSW?
Case Example: When Might the Court Deny Out of Time Applications?
In Morgan v Black [2023] NSWSC 1073, an application for an “out of time” family provision claim was made by the adult daughter of the deceased more than three years after her father’s death.
The Court found that there was no sufficient cause to allow the extension. There was no evidence that the daughter was unaware of the time limit for commencing the claim. No significant steps were taken by the daughter to obtain further legal advice, despite conducting internet searches about family provision claims and contesting wills, and discussing with another beneficiary the need to obtain legal advice.
The daughter’s loss of employment and limited funds to pay for legal advice were found to be unsatisfactory explanations for the excessive delay. The Court concluded that the daughter was waiting for a time that suited her, or that she had a change of mind or heart about bringing a claim.
Not Too Late?
Sir Reginald Ansett died on 23 December 1981. On 18 January 2006, 24 years after his death, the deceased’s two sons made an application to extend the time to commence a claim for further provision from their father’s estate.
The application was refused at first instance, but leave was granted for an appeal of that decision, which was successful in Ansett v Moss [2007] VSCA 161. The deceased’s youngest son, John Ansett, was then granted further provision from his father’s estate in a new trial.
It can be difficult to know whether you can make an “out of time” application for family provision. If you are unsure about the relevant timeframes or whether you may be eligible to make a claim, HFK Lawyers can help you understand your options and next steps.
For advice about family provision claims, contesting a will or estate disputes, please contact our Estates team on (02) 9307 8900.